Scrapbook: The Lord of the Rings
March 12, 2024 Leave a comment
I’m not a huge fan of the Universes Beyond sets—half of them aren’t even fantasy settings! But when I heard that they were doing a Lord of the Rings set, I got a bit excited. I love the books, and it is a fantasy setting well suited to a Magic treatment. Then, they did some really cool things with the cards: The panorama scene cards are really neat! The showcase treatments are fun! And they made nine different Nazgul!
I wanted to collect the cards from this set, but alas! Too many of the cards ended up really pricey. Some of this is just the typical priciness that comes from the popularity of Commander these days, so OK, I guess. But what I really take issue with is allowing these cards into competitive Magic. Sure, they’re not in Standard, but in my opinion, they shouldn’t be in Legacy or Modern either. I suppose Vintage could be the one place where any card ever printed can go, but Vintage has already priced most people out of it, so the demand wouldn’t be so great anyway.
I did build a couple of decks from the set: The Hobbits of the Shire vs. Sauron, Lord of Mordor, but I had to proxy up the Nazgul. As a casual player, I can live with that. But there was no way I was going to be able to collect all the cool cards—The One Ring is going for over $50! And the Nazgul are each about $10. So, I had to be satisfied with my two weak decks, and a digital scrapbook for the set. Here it is: